Bam! Right on cue! To follow-up on my last post, John McCain went ahead and accused Obama of playing the race card. An accusation like this is the granddaddy of resentment stoking, and honestly, it seems like it almost came a little early.
The line in question? Obama in Missouri:
“what they’re going to try to do is make you scared of me. You know, he’s not patriotic enough. He’s got a funny name. You know, he doesn’t look like all those other Presidents on those dollar bills, you know. He’s risky. That’s essentially the argument they’re making.”
Not to get all stuff white people like on you here, but this is the thing- calling a white person a honky or a cracker or even whitey doesn’t have much impact, doesn’t leave a guy feeling like his identity’s been stripped and he’s not being seen as a complex human being- that’s what words like nigger and spic and gook do. The only thing you can call a white person that makes him feel the way a person of color feels when someone hurls one of those power words their direction is racist. That’s when white people flip the fuck out, because it means we’re not being given a chance to explain ourselves, we’re being pre-emptively branded as bad.
So when McCain complains that Obama’s playing the race card, what he’s doing is complaining that Obama called him racist. Now, A-1, he didn’t do that, and B-2, McCain’s new attacks are racist, so what’s the point of the complaint? The point is that every half-bright dickhead in Dogshit, Indiana who hears this thinks back to times when he’s been called a racist for just tellin’ it like it is, or being scared of the black kids he saw at the mall last week, and how angry that made him. Or maybe he thinks about OJ Simpson and Johnny Cochrane and the way they played the race card to get a murderer off, and the injustice of it all… And now here’s this Obama guy, doing the same thing…
And that’s how the politics of resentment work. You don’t have to make a point. You just have to make people who already have some resentment bubbling away feel like your opponent represents all of the things you find so loathsome. And then you paint yourself as the guy who’s just like them, just a simple, hardworking fella out to do his best in this world, without presumptuous minorities acting like victims all the time, but getting called these awful things just for saying what everybody knows is true… Keep at it, make that association stick, and then you’re onto it. Suddenly it’s not McCain against Obama, it’s Regular Folks against The Race Card, or The PC Police, or The Goddamn Hippies, and you didn’t have to do a thing to make the case for yourself to suddenly end up the de facto symbol for a vision of a certain kind of America, running against the things everyone decent can agree are ruining this once-great land of ours.
So where do you go from here? Well, that’s the trick. Because this is a grease fire, y’all- you can’t put it out with water. You can’t offer a cogent, rational outline for why what your opponent said is untrue, because they’re not engaging people on a rational level, they’re hitting them viscerally. You either hit back with the same sort of dirty shit, or you hold out hope that there aren’t enough mean-spirited jerks running around America to get this to pay off. But nobody ever lost a bet by underestimating the American public’s taste for slime.
2 responses so far ↓
1 m.s. // Aug 1, 2008 at 3:47 am
I’m not really sure what the appropriate response is… and while B-rock is currently very good at being inspirational, and all that biz, I’m not sure how much of it is really because of things he’s doing on purpose… when he wants to do do things on purpose, he seems to take a nuanced, rational approach to things. Which isn’t really going to help in this instance.
Once people start thinking in terms of “dirty fucking hippies spittin’ on our veterans” then there’s not many approaches, gut level or not, that you can take to change their mind, if they think you’re a dirty fucking hippie itchin’ to spit on the coffin of soldier. Or dance on the grave of Ronald Reagan. Or whatever. About the only thing that can make a difference is direct human interaction with the enemy that leads to a positive experience.
I’m not certain there ARE enough annoying asswipes willing to go out there and vote for McCain just to keep whitey in the White House, but there MIGHT be. Which, frankly, scares the shit out of me. Worse, even than it did in 2004.
If they keep it up, about the only thing that could redeem Obama in the eyes of the people that will slowly grow to hate him will be doing something physically brave in some unforeseen dire and terrible situation, I think. Like him being on the scene of a terrorist attack, and digging through the wreckage himself to save friends and family, while his giant army of campaign volunteers mobilizes to help. Horrible shit that ends up with people dead, basically.
So mostly I’m just hoping that sense prevails.
2 admin // Aug 1, 2008 at 10:12 am
I think the ad I would run as a counter to this would be something along the lines of, “John McCain thinks you’re so easily distracted that you’re more concerned with Britney Spears and Paris Hilton and accusations about race than your own lives”- something that says, basically, “we have more faith in you than this”, and leaves a positive association in the mind of the viewer with not falling for it. It has to happen soon- like, by early next week- but it’d counter the worst of it better than complaining that McCain’s a big dickhead who is playing dirty, which seems to be the approach…
–d
Leave a Comment